Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer
True crimeReal cases, told as documentary or drama.This show: 10/10DocuseriesNonfiction storytelling across episodes.This show: 9/10DisturbingContent that lingers uncomfortably after the credits.This show: 7/10Dark toneShadowy mood and subject matter, a shade short of outright bleak.This show: 7/10
Rate this series
Starring
Aaron Peck
Starring
Aaron Peck
Ratings per Episode
Votes per Episode
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer Episode Ratings Heatmap
| Avg | E1 | E2 | E3 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | 7.2 | 7.0 | 7.2 | 7.3 |
Download Infographic
About
This tense true-crime series examines the hunt for the Long Island serial killer through the perspective of his victims, their loved ones and the police.
All Seasons
▼
Miniseries2025
7.282332h 38m
| Ep | Title | Rating | Yours | Votes | Runtime | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ▶ | 1 | Part One | 7.0 | 287 | 49 min | |
| ▶ | 2 | Part Two | 7.2 | 270 | 56 min | |
| ▶ | 3 | Part Three | 7.3 | 266 | 53 min |
Full Cast & Crew
Cast
Robert Kolker Self - Author, Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery, Self - Journalist, New York magazine
Jaclyn Gallucci Self - Journalist, Long Island Press
Melissa Cann Self - Sister of Maureen Brainard-Barnes
Geraldine Hart Self - Senior Agent, Long Island FBI, Self - Suffolk County Police Commissioner 2018 - 2021
John Ray Self - Attorney for Mari Gilbert
Elizabeth Meserve Self - Aunt of Megan Waterman
Amanda Funderburg Self - Sister of Melissa Barthelemy
Dave Schaller Self - Friend of Amber Costello
Bear Brodsky Self - Friend of Amber Costello
Aaron Peck Law Enforcement, Detective
Similar Series
Popular picks Shows that people who know this one usually know too. From our AI taste analysis.
Making a Murderer
108K 20 2015–2018
True crime · Docuseries · Cynical
Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes
35K 4 2019–2019
True crime · Docuseries
Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel
22K 4 2021–2021
True crime · Docuseries
I'll Be Gone in the Dark
10K 7 2020–2021
True crime · Docuseries
Our recommendations Specific picks with the reason, including shows you may not have heard of. From our AI taste analysis.
The Ripper
12K 4 2020–2020
botched serial killer investigation and police missteps
The Keepers
28K 7 2017–2017
unresolved cold case with systemic law enforcement failures
The Sons of Sam: A Descent into Darkness
11K 4 2021–2021
obsessive amateur investigators chasing a killer theory
American Nightmare
25K 3 2024–2024
police incompetence undermining a true crime case
Catching Killers
6K 12 2021–2023
detective-led perspective on hunting serial murderers
Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter
10K 2 2024–2024
grieving families pushing for justice in a stalled case
The Crime of the Century
5K 2 2021–2021
media-driven true crime storytelling of infamous cases
Cold Case Files
2K 127 1999–present
methodical forensic breakdown of long-unsolved murders
Close in taste Nearest neighbors in our taste profile comparison: shared tone, themes and style.