Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes poster

Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes

★ 7.1 15K votes 2022–2022 1 seasons · 3 episodes Ended Netflix
True crimeReal cases, told as documentary or drama.This show: 10/10DisturbingContent that lingers uncomfortably after the credits.This show: 9/10DocuseriesNonfiction storytelling across episodes.This show: 9/10Dark toneShadowy mood and subject matter, a shade short of outright bleak.This show: 8/10UnsettlingA creeping sense of unease and wrongness that gets under your skin.This show: 7/10Emotionally heavyDemands real emotional stamina from the viewer.This show: 7/10
Rate this series
Ratings per Episode
246810
Votes per Episode
0200400600800

Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes Episode Ratings Heatmap

AvgE1E2E3
S17.47.37.47.5

Download Infographic

Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes episode ratings heatmap infographic

The full episode-rating heatmap as a shareable image.

About

"A killer's own voice unravels his lies"

This documentary uses newly surfaced audio tapes of John Wayne Gacy talking about his own case, paired with interviews from investigators, survivors, and family members of victims. It reconstructs how a seemingly ordinary suburban contractor and community volunteer committed a string of murders in 1970s Chicago while evading suspicion for years. The tone is grim and clinical rather than sensational, letting Gacy's own rationalizations play out at length. It's slow-building and heavy on archival detail, carried less by narrative momentum than by the unsettling experience of hearing a killer describe himself in his own words.

Watch it for

the unsettling access to Gacy's actual recorded voice explaining away his crimes.

Maybe skip if

you find true-crime interview formats repetitive or need dramatized reenactments to stay engaged.

Written by our AI editor to help you decide, spoiler-free by design.

All Seasons

Limited Series2022
7.42K33h 4m
Never-before-heard audio from the interrogation of serial killer John Wayne Gacy threads through this chilling look at his 1970s murder spree.
EpTitleRatingYoursVotesRuntime
1The Life of the Party7.3
72264 min
2A Nicely Kept Secret7.4
67160 min
3Sane Enough7.5
64960 min

Full Cast & Crew

Cast

Sam Amirante Self - Gacy's Criminal Attorney
Greg Bedoe Self - Investigator, Cook County
Rafael Tovar Self - Des Plaines P.D.
Mike Albrecht Self - Des Plaines P.D.
Terry Sullivan Self - Prosecutor, Cook County
Steve Nemmers Self - Waterloo, Iowa Resident
Kim Byers-Lund Self - Rob Piest's Friend
Lawrence Finder Self - Prosecutor, Cook County
Ron Robinson Self - Des Plaines P.D.
Patti Vasquez Self - Michael Bonnin's Sister

Similar Series

Close in taste Nearest neighbors in our taste profile comparison: shared tone, themes and style.